Court Hears Arguments in Navy Sonar Case
1 Comment Published by Kedar S. Bhatia October 9th, 2008 in Constitutional Law, Supreme CourtThe Supreme Court yesterday heard arguments in Winter v. Natural Resources Defense Council, a case revolving around Navy sonar exercises off the coast of California and their potential impact on the environment. Justices on both sides of the normal ideological division seemed unpersuaded by the NRDC. Justice Breyer at one time asked, I will express [...]
Justices Hear Arguments in Altria Group v. Good
1 Comment Published by Kedar S. Bhatia October 8th, 2008 in Constitutional Law, Supreme CourtThe Court convened Monday to begin the new term and first heard oral arguments in Altria Group v. Good. The case revolves around whether or not federal labeling regulations on the use of ‘light’ or ‘low-tar’ cigarettes preempts state deceptive advertising claims. Theodore Olsen opened arguments on the day on behalf of the tobacco companies [...]
Surprisingly Candid McCain and Obama Discuss Current SCOTUS Makeup, Nomination Process at the Saddleback Civil Forum
2 Comments Published by James August 17th, 2008 in Antonin Scalia, Barack Obama, Clarence Thomas, David Souter, John Paul Stevens, John Roberts, Judges and Justices, Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Samuel Alito, Stephen Breyer, Supreme CourtEarlier tonight, Senators John McCain and Barack Obama joined Pastor Rick Warren at his California megachurch for an event pegged as “The Saddleback Civil Forum on the Presidency.” The interviews, each an hour in length, were separated by thirty-six tense seconds in which the presumptive nominees shared the stage (and an awkward hug [video here!]). [...]
Supreme Court Hands Down Key Opinions
0 Comments Published by Kedar S. Bhatia June 25th, 2008 in Constitutional Law, Supreme CourtThe Supreme Court today handed down a series opinions on the penultimate day of the term. Major thanks should go to SCOTUSblog for getting these opinions online minutes after the Court announces them. I’ll eventually change the links to redirect to the Supreme Court’s website, but thanks go to SCOTUSblog for letting us read the [...]
Kelo Turns Three Today
0 Comments Published by Kedar S. Bhatia June 23rd, 2008 in Constitutional Law, Supreme CourtThe Supreme Court’s landmark public use decision Kelo v. City of New London was handed down three years ago today. On June 23, 2005, Justices Stevens handed down an opinion that held that “there is no basis for exempting economic development from our traditionally broad understanding of public purpose.” Justices Kennedy, Souter, Breyer, and Ginsburg [...]
Thoughts on US v. Ressam
0 Comments Published by Kedar S. Bhatia May 28th, 2008 in Constitutional Law, Supreme CourtUS v. Williams (opinion) stole the spotlight amongst last week’s decided cases and for good reason. The court narrowed scope of the PROTECT Act and upheld its basic tenants against first amendment claims. Another case, US v. Ressam, struck me as being particularly interesting. The facts of Ressam (opinion) aren’t terribly complex. Ahmed Ressam tried [...]
Supreme Court Upholds Application of Lethal Injection
1 Comment Published by Kedar S. Bhatia April 16th, 2008 in Constitutional Law, Supreme CourtThe Supreme Court handed down one of the most high-profile decisions of its term, the lethal injection case Baze v. Rees. The Court upheld Kentucky’s use of the execution method, holding that “that petitioners have not shown that the risk of an inadequate dose of the first drug is substantial.” Chief Justice Roberts wrote the [...]
Supreme Court Hands Down Drunk Driving Opinion
1 Comment Published by Kedar S. Bhatia April 16th, 2008 in Constitutional Law, Supreme CourtThe Supreme Court today handed down an opinion in Begay v. US in which it held that drunk driving is not a violent felony as defined by particular sentencing regulations. Justice Breyer authored a six-Justice majority opinion that concluded that drunk driving does not fall into a category of behavior that “otherwise involves conduct that [...]
Which Justice Will Author The Medellin Opinion?
0 Comments Published by Kedar S. Bhatia March 19th, 2008 in Court Procedure, Supreme CourtMedellin (docket, questions presented, oral arguments, petitioner’s brief) is without a doubt one of the most anticipated opinions of the year. Medellin was argued on October 10, 2007, making it one of the oldest cases still being decided. As of today, it has been nearly 160 days since Medellin‘s oral arguments and last year, the [...]
The always-insightful New York Times Magazine has an interesting article on the Court entitled “Supreme Court Inc.” Jeffery Rosen takes a look into the Court to determine why it has become so receptive to big business and comes to some pretty interesting, if not particularly unexpected conclusions. Though the current Supreme Court has a well-earned [...]


