A Lighthearted Look at OT08
0 Comments Published by Kedar August 25th, 2009 in Constitutional Law, Supreme CourtJohn Elwood has posted a link to the end-of-term recap that he wrote for the Green Bag. As Elwood points out, the article is available for “a price commensurate with its worth.” I’ve probably said it before but I’ll say it again: I’m a big fan of the Green Bag and I’d recommend it to [...]
Northwest Austin Municipal Utility District and the Future of Section 5
0 Comments Published by Kedar June 24th, 2009 in Constitutional Law, Election Law, Supreme CourtBy now, you should all know that the Supreme Court handed down their long-awaited decision in Northwest Austin Municipal Utility District No. 1 v. Holder. In short, the Chief Justice Roberts wrote for a nearly unanimous court holding that Section 5 was bad and faced several constitutional problems, but the Court decided to give Congress [...]
Justice Souter’s Concurring Opinion in US v. Navajo Nation
0 Comments Published by Kedar April 6th, 2009 in Constitutional Law, David Souter, Supreme CourtIn US v. Navajo Nation, the Court affirmed their decision from six years ago to limit the royalties that the Native American tribe could collect from coal deals made several decades ago. Justice Souter filed a brief concurrence, printed here in its entirety: I am not through regretting that my position in United States v. [...]
Supreme Court Hands Down Opinion in Federal Pre-emption case
0 Comments Published by Kedar March 4th, 2009 in Clarence Thomas, Constitutional Law, John Paul Stevens, Justices and Judges, Supreme CourtThe Supreme Court handed down an opinion today in Wyeth v. Levine (here). (29) Wyeth v. Levine Docket Filing | Questions Presented Case Number: 06-1249 On Appeal From: SC-VT Date Argued: November 3, 2008 Date Decided: March 4, 2009 6-3; Affirmed Majority: Stevens(m), Kennedy, Souter, Ginsburg, Breyer(c), Thomas(c) Dissent: Alito(d), Roberts, Scalia Days between argument [...]
Supreme Court Further Constricts Article III Taxpayer Standing
0 Comments Published by Kedar March 3rd, 2009 in Antonin Scalia, Constitutional Law, Supreme CourtThe Supreme Court continued its quest to strike at Article III taxpayer standing today in its opinion in Summers v. Earth Island Institute (here). In 1968, the Court ruled 8-1 in Flast v. Cohen (here) that Florence Flast and others could file suit against the Secretary of Health, Education, and Welfare for violating the First [...]
Supreme Court Releases Opinions in Pearson, Fitzgerald, Locke, and Waddington
0 Comments Published by Kedar January 21st, 2009 in Constitutional Law, Supreme CourtAs expected, the Supreme Court handed down several opinions today. Waddington v. Sarausad
A Prevailing Change In The Way The Supreme Court Manages The Circuits
0 Comments Published by Kedar January 21st, 2009 in Constitutional Law, Court Procedure, John Roberts, Samuel Alito, Supreme CourtThe Supreme Court has long been criticized for poorly patrolling its lower courts for circuit splits. At least recently, the Supreme Court has issued relatively few summary judgements and summary reversals to clarify its recent decisions before they grow out of hand. The Court today did just that when they summarily reversed a decision of [...]
Supreme Court Issues Per Curiam Opinion Clarifying Kimbrough
0 Comments Published by Kedar January 21st, 2009 in Constitutional Law, Sentencing, Supreme CourtThe Supreme Court released a Per Curiam opinion in Spears v. US clarifying its position on the crack/cocaine ratio that it took last year in Kimbrough v. US (2007). The Court ruled that district courts may “categorically disagree” with the advisory 100:1 crack/power cocaine ratio and may choose at will to implement a new standard [...]
Initial Thoughts on Ricci v. DeStefano
0 Comments Published by Kedar January 19th, 2009 in Affirmative Action, Constitutional Law, Supreme Court[UPDATE]: On February 25, 2009, I filed a brief as amicus curiae in this case. You can find it here. Last week, the court granted review in Ricci v. DeStefano. In 2003, the city of New Haven attempted to promote a number of firefighters to the ranks of captain and lieutenant based on a number [...]
The Broad Scope of Herring
0 Comments Published by Kedar January 14th, 2009 in Constitutional Law, Fourth Amendment, John Roberts, Supreme CourtEarlier this morning, the Supreme Court held in Herring v. United States that non-systematic negligence by police officers fall within the scope of the good-faith exception to the exclusionary rule. I wrote about the case after oral arguments here. The decision of the conservative majority to significantly expand the scope of the good-faith exception to [...]



