To sum up my views on the oral arguments today: we saw it coming. Justice Sotomayor lined up in exactly the position she was expected take and the same goes for each of the other eight Justices. In the end, it looks like her position will be a minority one.

Solicitor General Kagan did a fantastic job for her first oral argument. Her position was a difficult one and the Justices who disagree with her position certainly held no punches. Chief Justice Roberts, in particular, went after her position and commented on some aspects of the SG’s uncomfortably paternalistic position. Admittedly though, this was an interest set of arguments because each Justice seemed more clear than usual in the position they would be taking.

I’d recommend this set of oral arguments to anyone with an interest in the Court. The parties made some pretty interesting, well-laid out claims. As soon as we get the transcript I’m sure the (laugher.) count will be very high. You can find an audio recording from c-span here.


Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Categories

Random Posts

  • January Hearing List Released: The Supreme Court has released the Hearing List for the January sitting and you can find it here. Several high-profile advocates are back...
  • First Opinion Stats: As we wait for the first opinion of the term, I thought it would be interesting to take a look at the first signed opinion released in recen...
  • More Sophisticated Reconferencing Statistics: A commentator on my last conferencing post picked up on an important part of the distribution question that I had intentionally omitted....
  • Measuring Justice Sotomayor's Liberal Bona Fides: Justice Sotomayor has completed two years on the Supreme Court and, as she begins her third, it seems like an appropriate time to take an in...
  • New Opinions and Updated Statistics: The Supreme Court released three new opinions today and dismissed one hotly-anticipated case as improvidently granted. Graham v. Florida-...