Howard Friedman reports on his blog, Religion Clause, that a cert. petition has been filed in Oliver v. Quarterman, a case revolving around whether or not a juror’s use of the bible constitutes grounds for a mistrial.

Khristian Oliver claims that a juror member’s reading of the bible during a case represents an ‘external influence,’ preventing the juror from considering only the facts of the case and relevant statute. The Fifth Circuit held in August that, while improper, the use of a bible is not per se grounds for reconsideration. They argued that Oliver had not shown sufficient evidence to prove that the bible influenced the juror (or his or her peers) to make a decision they would not have made otherwise.

In October, the court denied cert. in a similar case arrising from the Texas Court Of Criminal Appeals (opinion of the TCCA here). That case, Lucero v. Texas, centered around a jury foreman who read aloud passages from the bible after he found out that two jurors were unwilling to impose the death penalty. The passages, Romans 13:1-6, had the desired effect and the two jurors changed voted to recommend the death penalty. As usual, the Supreme Court denied cert. without issuing any statement.


Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Categories

Random Posts

  • Predicting the April Sitting: I run into the exact same debate every year around mid-January: which cases will be heard during the current term and which will be pushed o...
  • A Big Little Case: Next Wednesday, the Supreme Court will hear arguments in an interesting case about water law in Montana, PPL Montana v. Montana. The case wi...
  • Update: List Of Advocates Who Have Argued Twice In A Month: Four days ago, I posted a list of the advocates who have argued twice during a single month since 2003. Well, that chart is already outdated...
  • January Hearing List Released: The Supreme Court has released the Hearing List for the January sitting and you can find it here. Several high-profile advocates are back...
  • PDF Packs for the Past Decade: I've been pillaging the Supreme Court's website in search of PDFs that I can archive for future reference. Using the Court's website and the...