Once again, I’ve conjured up some charts marking how often each Justice spoke during oral arguments in the first half of the term. You can find a detailed look into my methodology here but to summarize, these numbers represent the number of times ‘JUSTICE ______’ is mentioned in the oral argument transcripts posted on the Court’s website here. Searching only for the capitalized phrase eliminates catching respectful mentions of the Justices from counsel. Click on the files to see a larger image.

Overall Stats

Once again, Justice Scalia comes in as the most talkative and averages 21 comments per hour of arguments. That shouldn’t surprise many people as he has always been known to be a particularly vocal member of the court. Justice Thomas still hasn’t spoken since February 22, 2006. Chief Justice Roberts and Justice Breyer both average about 18 comments per case. On the other side of the spectrum, Justice Alito spoke an average of only 5 times per case. Justices Stevens, Kennedy, and Ginsburg spoke with similar frequency at 12, 11, and 10 times per argument, respectively.

Speaking per circuit

This chart covers the difference between Justices’s overall speaking average and their average per individual court. I’ve highlighted the times when justices had variations of greater than 5 in either direction. I was particularly surprised to see that Ninth Circuit Cases had very little effect on justices, and, if anything, they actually spoke slightly less than usual.

When more cases start coming down, I’ll be interested to see what effect speaking frequency has on voting. Does Justice Kennedy speak more when he votes in favor of a case? Do Justices Stevens or Scalia speak more when they think a case will come down 5-4? With only 2 cases decided on merit thus far, its hard to say at this point but I’ll keep track of the decisions as they come down and post when I’ve collected enough data for some basic analysis.

You can find the data in these formats: xls, numbers, and, of course, pdf. Feel free to play with the data and let me know what conclusions you come up with!


Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Categories

Random Posts

  • Belated Decade Advocate Scorecard: For one reason or another, it looks like I forgot to post my updated advocate scorecard for the decade at the end of the last term. Origin...
  • Who is Roy W. McLeese?: This morning, as I was perusing next month's hearing list, I noticed a name I wasn't familiar with: Roy W. McLeese. It isn't unusual to see ...
  • A Big Little Case: Next Wednesday, the Supreme Court will hear arguments in an interesting case about water law in Montana, PPL Montana v. Montana. The case wi...
  • Update: List Of Advocates Who Have Argued Twice In A Month: Four days ago, I posted a list of the advocates who have argued twice during a single month since 2003. Well, that chart is already outdated...
  • Nearly Final Term Statistics and Advocate Scorecard: My goal was to publish the final term statistics today, but because the Court will hear rearguments in Citzens United and likely issue an op...