It has been a busy couple of weeks for all those folks runnin’ for President!

Of course, everyone has something to say about Bush’s decision to commute ol’ Scooter’s sentence (you can find a detailed and thought-provoking run down here, courtesy of DryFlyPolitics). Then, yesterday, the final fundraising numbers for the previous quarter came in. Gary explained here how dangerous these numbers could prove for a stumbling McCain, but our pals at BlogsForBush also noted that Hillary could be in some serious trouble. That’s okay, though, because her Sopranos rip-off (discussed at length here by the cats over at Open Forum) was a great hit. Right? Right. According to our Election Tracker, both Mlle. Clinton and M. Giuliani seem to be enjoying (very) comfortable leads in national polling (click thumbnail to enlarge via lightbox):

2008 Republican Primary Graph from DailyWrit
^^^(Republican National Primary Preferences)^^^
2008 Democratic Primary Graph from DailyWrit
^^^(Democratic National Primary Preferences)^^^

Giuliani, however, trails Mitt Romney (R-MA) by sizeable margins in BOTH Iowa and New Hampshire, as you can see in DailyWrit’s graphs below (again, click thumbnails to enlarge):

2008 Republican Iowa Caucus Graph from DailyWrit
^^^(Iowa Caucus Polling Among Republicans)^^^
2008 Republican New Hampshire Graph from DailyWrit
^^^(New Hampshire Primary Polling Among Republicans)^^^

He’s also slipping against Clinton in models of the General Election (you know the drill):

Giuliani vs. Clinton Graph (Updated July 3)

This could get bad for Rudy. He started strong, but it don’t take a genius to interpret those trendlines as a bad sign. Iowa is January 14 (DailyWrit’s full calendar of primaries and caucuses here), and he can’t seem to get it to together. He SHOULD be running away with this. Afterall, McCain is 473 years old and Mitt Romney sucked as Governor of MA. But he’s not. If Rudy finishes third in either of these two primaries, he better start campaigning to be somebody’s VP. In all seriousness, Giuliani is more an asset to the RNC at the bottom of the ticket than he is at the top. A pro-choice, pro-gun control, anti-anti-gay candidate screams of bipartisanship – which is the stuff of electability in a General Election. Unforunately, none of these admirable positions has anything to do with ethanol or farming subsidies, and, thusly, they won’t win Rudy any votes in Iowa. Nonetheless, his open-minded stances are very noticeable and, earlier this week, earned him a pseudo-endorsement from Joe Lieberman (explained here by Ian Schwartz). All of this got me thinking. I really think that the GOP stands the best chance with Romney/Giuliani, for several reasons:

1). Giuliani puts New York in play, which, if nothing else, forces Democrats to put some money into a state they would prefer to take for granted.
2). Pro-life/Pro-choice has something for everyone. Pro-choice/Pro-choice doesn’t.
3). These guys are from beyond the establishment. Let’s not pretend for any longer than we absolutely have to that McCain’s record (specifically, the S&L Scandal (more specifically, the Keating Five)) won’t come up as we creep towards Iowa.
4). Donor variability. Rudy (and his liberal social politics) might get a second look from leftist donors. That’s the kind of look that Clinton/Obama would never get from the NRA or a similar(ly wealthy) organization.
5). Romney needs someone who we know because (lets not kid ourselves!)…who is Mitt Romney? Seriously. He’s a Massachusetts Republican with a hot wife. Anybody got anything else? I don’t.
6). They essentially agree on the economy.
7). Watch the debates. These guys are good.

1 Response to “Model Suggests Romney/Giuliani May Be a Winning Permutation in the General Election”

  1. 1 Candidate Profile: Mitt Romney at DailyWrit

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.


Random Posts

  • Advocates who have argued twice during a single sitting (OT03-Present): In honor of Carter Phillips arguing twice during the December sitting of the Court, I've compiled a list of every instance of this phenomeno...
  • Updated Term Stats: Term Index Vote Breakdown Vote Breakdown Stats --- You can see from the Term Index that Justice Stevens is the most likely author of...
  • Updates: I've updated a lot of the information on the Term Case Index in preparation for today's cases. I expect the Supreme Court to hand down 1-2 o...
  • Advocate Scorecard for OT00-Present: This weekend, I went through all the oral argument transcripts from OT00 through OTO8 and I counted how many times each of the major advocat...
  • Measuring Justice Sotomayor's Liberal Bona Fides: Justice Sotomayor has completed two years on the Supreme Court and, as she begins her third, it seems like an appropriate time to take an in...